In the past year alone, we’ve seen brands like Summer Fridays, Rare Beauty, and many others launch variations of the same theme: Glossy but not sticky, treatment-meets-makeup lip products promising juicy, hydrated lips minus the tacky texture we knew (and definitely didn’t love) in the aughts. But in the spirit of fewer, better things, I’ve managed to whittle down my collection to three standouts that are liquid gold — er, pinky nude. Below, find out which ones have stood the test of time.